Reproducing Quiznos’ Broccoli Cheese Soup: Part 2 in My Search for the Perfect Broccoli Cheese Soup Recipe

Natalie Dee comics - don't eat your broccoli friends

Broccoli is your friend, not your enemy!

Welcome to Part 2 of my 3-Part Miniseries on my search for the perfect broccoli cheese soup recipe.

In Part 1, I blogged about my failed attempt at finding the perfect broccoli cheese soup recipe in The Martha Stewart Living Cookbook: The New Classics (mostly because the only broccoli soup that’s listed in the cookbook isn’t necessarily a cheesy broccoli soup, per se… but rather a regular broccoli soup that’s topped with cheese toasts. Definitely didn’t pass the satisfaction test for a good, quality cheesy broccoli soup!).

In this post, I’ll be blogging about my attempt at reproducing the broccoli and cheese soup that started this whole obsession to begin with… that being, Quiznos’ Broccoli Cheese Soup.

Quiznos Broccoli Cheese Soup

The end product that I want to recreate: Quiznos' Broccoli Cheese Soup

As I had mention in Part 1, I’ve been in love with broccoli and cheese soups ever since I first tried Quiznos‘ version. It’s thick. It’s super cheesy. And it’s delicious! I’ve definitely never had another broccoli and cheese soup since that beats its.

So while my first attempt at finding the perfect broccoli and cheese soup failed, my second attempt carried through spectacularly without a hitch!

What did I do for my second attempt, you ask? I basically searched online for a copycat recipe for Quiznos’ Broccoli Cheese Soup, and found this one (see below for full recipe). Gave it a whirl, and boy was the resulting soup WAY better than my first attempt with Martha Stewart’s Broccoli Soup with Cheddar Toasts!

It tastes pretty freaking identical to Quiznos’ version… but less salty (since I made sure to use stock with no additional salt added), and doesn’t have that “preserved” taste that commercially produced food items tend to possess. I should also mention that instead of half and half, I opted to use whole milk… and it turned out fine.

Anyway, I give this recipe a very solid 2 thumbs up!

Here is the copycat recipe reproducing Quiznos’ Broccoli and Cheese Soup.


P.S. Stay tuned for Part 3 of my 3-Part Miniseries in search for the perfect broccoli cheese soup recipe… I’ll be attempting to reproduce Subway’s Broccoli and Cheese Soup with another copycat recipe!)
Lost? View Legend of Knitting and Purling Blog Categories and Tags
Filed Under These Blog Categories...
Director of Search Marketing by day, die hard knitter by night. Arts and crafts lover. One of a kind jewelry designer. Supporter of buying handmade. Stylishly domestic homemaker. Frugal shopaholic. Shutterbug. Globetrotter. Geek girl who ❤s computer nerds. Blogger for the Knitting and Purling blog.
Google Plus icon Twitter icon Facebook icon Email icon
Broccoli comic courtesy of Natalie Dee. Quiznos' Broccoli Cheese Soup image courtesy of Computer graphics edited by the Knitting and Purling blog.

Shop Geeky Gifts for Computer Nerds!

Shop geeky gifts for computer nerds at the Knitting and Purling store

Leave a comment